When I first tried mapping a buyer journey, I made a chart so beautiful it could've hung in a gallery. Awareness stage here, consideration stage there, decision stage at the bottom with a satisfying arrow pointing to "PURCHASE." I color-coded it. I added customer personas with names and stock photos. I felt like a marketing genius.
Then I looked at our actual conversion data and realized my perfect map had almost nothing to do with how real humans actually found us, evaluated us, and decided to work with us.
The Real Truth About Buyer Journeys
Buyer journey mapping isn't about making pretty diagrams—it's about understanding the messy, nonlinear, surprisingly emotional path people actually take when they're trying to solve a problem.
Video Transcript
Ever feel lost in your marketing? Buyer journey mapping can be your guiding star. Today, I'll share five tips to streamline that customer journey and boost sales. First, tag every article for awareness, consideration, or decision stages. Find missing stages. Next, target three keyword types: problem, comparison, and vendor pricing for each topic. Also, connect awareness posts to deeper comparison guides with soft links for engagement. Remember, for every three awareness pieces, create one consideration and one decision piece. Don't forget, interview recent customers and turn their questions into valuable content. Curious about the missing piece of your buyer journey? Discover it in our full playbook.
What Is Buyer Journey Mapping (And Why Most People Get It Wrong)
Picture this: It's a foggy morning in Manzanita. You're craving coffee. You don't know the area. What do you do?
- Google "coffee near me" (awareness: I need coffee, what exists?)
- Click on a few options, check reviews, look at photos (consideration: which place seems good?)
- Choose based on distance, vibe, and whether they have oat milk (decision: I'm going there)
That's a buyer journey. Three stages. Multiple touchpoints. Real human behavior.
The Three Buyer Journey Stages That Actually Matter
Stage 1 Awareness: "I have a problem"
Your buyer doesn't know you exist yet. They barely know they have a problem. They're Googling things like "why isn't my marketing working" or "how to get more website traffic."
They're not looking for solutions yet. They're looking for clarity, education, and validation that what they're experiencing is real and fixable.
Wrong Content
"Book a free consultation!" "Our pricing is competitive!" "We're the #1 solution!"
Right Content
"7 Reasons Your Content Isn't Getting Traffic" or "Why Good Marketing Feels Invisible: A Guide for Frustrated Founders"
Stage 2 Consideration: "What are my options?"
Your buyer knows what they need. Now they're evaluating approaches, comparing methodologies, and figuring out what kind of solution fits their situation.
They're Googling things like "content gap analysis vs keyword research" or "DIY content strategy vs hiring experts."
Wrong Content
"Contact us today!" (too early) or "Here's what SEO is" (too basic—they're past that)
Right Content
"Content Gap Analysis: What It Is, How It Works, and When You Need It" or "DIY Content Strategy vs Agency: An Honest Comparison"
Stage 3 Decision: "Convince me you're the right choice"
Your buyer has narrowed their options. They're evaluating specific vendors, reading case studies, checking reviews, and looking for proof that you can actually deliver.
They're ready to buy. They're looking for proof, differentiation, and reasons to trust you specifically.
Wrong Content
"What is content marketing?" (way too basic) or generic thought leadership
Right Content
"Content Gap AI Case Studies: How Oregon Businesses Grew Traffic 300%+" or "What to Expect: Inside Our Content Audit Process"
How to Align Content with Intent
Step 1: Audit Your Current Content by Journey Stage
Open your blog. Look at your last twenty posts. For each one, ask: What stage is this serving?
If you're like most businesses, you'll find:
- 60% awareness content (because it's easiest to write)
- 30%... honestly you're not sure (it's just "thought leadership")
- 10% decision content (probably case studies someone made you write)
- 0% true consideration content
That Gap in the Middle?
That's why people aren't converting. They find your awareness content (great!), learn something useful (excellent!), and then... leave. Because you have nothing for them when they're ready to evaluate solutions.
Step 2: Map Keywords to Buyer Journey Stages
For every major topic you want to rank for, you need keywords that serve all three stages:
Awareness Keywords
- "why content marketing isn't working" (problem recognition)
- "how to increase website traffic" (solution searching)
- "content marketing mistakes" (pain point validation)
Consideration Keywords
- "content gap analysis vs traditional SEO" (comparison)
- "how to choose content strategy approach" (evaluation)
- "DIY content marketing vs agency" (options weighing)
Decision Keywords
- "Content Gap AI review" (vendor research)
- "content strategy agency pricing" (buying process)
- "content audit what to expect" (conversion confidence)
Common Buyer Journey Mapping Mistakes
Assuming Linear Paths
Real humans don't go Awareness → Consideration → Decision neatly. They bounce around, leave and come back, research for months.
The Fix
Create content for all stages simultaneously and make it easy to jump between them. Internal linking is your friend.
Only Top-of-Funnel Content
You have 47 blog posts about general industry topics and zero content helping people evaluate whether your solution is right for them.
The Fix
For every 3 awareness posts, create 1 consideration post and 1 decision post. Balance your content across the journey.
Getting Aggressive Too Early
Someone reads one blog post and you're hitting them with popups and "BOOK A CALL NOW" banners. They just met you.
The Fix
Match your CTAs to the journey stage. Awareness content → CTA for more educational content. Decision content → CTA for consultation.
Key Takeaways
- Tag each article as Awareness, Consideration, or Decision and find the missing stages
- For each topic, target three keyword types: problem, comparison, and vendor/pricing
- Add soft "next-step" links from Awareness posts to deeper Comparison guides
- For every 3 Awareness pieces, create 1 Consideration and 1 Decision piece
- Interview recent customers and turn their exact questions into journey-stage content